Board-on-Board (Shadowbox) vs Side-by-Side Cedar Fences

Trying to decide between board-on-board and side-by-side? Ask for both in the same quote and you’ll see the real price difference for your yard. Call, text, or send a few details.

Same cedar, different layout. Here’s how they compare.

Side-by-side

The pickets go edge to edge in a single row. It uses the least wood, so it’s the most affordable way to build a cedar privacy fence. The catch: cedar shrinks as it dries, and small gaps can open up between pickets over time. One side also shows the posts and rails, so you’ll have a “good side” and a “back side.”

Board-on-board (shadowbox)

The pickets overlap in two staggered rows, so there are no see-through gaps, even after the wood shrinks. It takes noticeably more pickets, so it costs more. Depending on how it’s built, it can look finished from both sides, which neighbors and HOAs tend to like.

Heads up: people use “shadowbox” for a couple of different layouts, sometimes meaning pickets that alternate sides of the rails. Ask to see exactly what’s being quoted.

Which one?

Go side-by-side if budget comes first and a few small gaps down the road don’t bother you. Go board-on-board if you want privacy that stays private and a fence that looks good from both sides, especially along a street, a neighbor, or an HOA with appearance rules. Either way, the posts matter more for how long the fence lasts; see cedar privacy fences.

Get a price on both. Call, text, or send us the details.

Ready to get your fence project going?

Call, text, or send a few details, and a local fence pro will get back to you with a price.